Silver Pines Review

A private eye searches for a missing musician in Silver Pines, a side-scrolling survival horror game inspired by Twin Peaks and Silent Hill.

Silver Pines. Credit: Wych Elm / Team17

Silver Pines from Wych Elm and publisher Team17 is a side-scrolling survival horror game with an unnerving atmosphere, a compelling mystery, and combat that takes patience to master. Its inspirations are transparent. It doesn’t hurt that I adore them, but the game still feels original.

You are private investigator Red Walker, searching the middle-of-nowhere town of Silver Pines for musician Eddie Velvet. You regularly check in with your mysterious client, who seems to have some kind of leverage over you and promises everything will be fine as long as you can find Velvet. Silver Pines is nearly abandoned. Only a few locals are left, and most of them seem… off.

The game’s story and vibe mash up Twin Peaks and Silent Hill. The small-town intrigue, strange cast of characters, and surreal, dreamlike sequences give way to something nastier when the town fills with monsters and sometimes transforms into a horrific otherworld. I ate it up.

You navigate the sprawling town, its buildings, and the areas beneath it from a side-on view. The areas are layered in 3D, so you can leave a screen through the foreground or background as well as to either side. Building interiors work the same way as you search from room to room. Movement is in the mold of classic cinematic platformers like Prince of Persia. Walking, running, and jumping have a realistic weight to them. You jump up to grab ledges and ease yourself down from them.

Silver Pines. Credit: Wych Elm / Team17

The town’s metroidvania-lite structure has you backtrack as you find stronger tools that can break through plastic, wood, and eventually stone barriers. Other items let you light dark rooms or swim. I found exploration rewarding and was eager to find every item and stat-boosting memento I could. The survival horror puzzles also send you back through town as you find the keys or other items you need to solve them. Knowing monsters could return to areas I’d already cleared made even familiar routes delightfully tense. Sometimes I got lost and had no idea where to go next, even with a map. It never bothered me.

The game also draws from Resident Evil, particularly in how you manage your inventory and save your progress. You can expand your inventory, but space is tight enough that using the magically interconnected storage boxes is a must. If an item isn’t immediately useful, you probably shouldn’t be carrying it. Some items, like healing supplies, can be combined to make stronger versions. To save, you call a number from one of the payphones scattered around town, and the call costs money. Money isn’t exactly rare, but you also need it to buy supplies from vending machines, so I was judicious about when I saved. It’s a little more forgiving than classic Resident Evil’s ink ribbons, but not by much.

Combat is challenging but fair. A well-timed dodge lets you avoid damage entirely, and every creature gives you openings to get in close and smack it with a melee weapon. Ranged weapons are safer, but my instinct in games like this is to conserve as much ammo as I can. Enemies never drop it. You have to find it around town or buy it from a vending machine. Melee weapons can break, too, so you’ll need duct tape or repair kits to keep them in shape. Sometimes it’s wiser to avoid enemies altogether. Some won’t attack until you make noise.

Silver Pines. Credit: Wych Elm / Team17

The rhythm of combat and the excellent sound design make firing a gun feel good and melee hits feel juicy. Reloading guns and fixing melee weapons each trigger a minigame that makes the work feel tactile but also adds to the challenge. Reloading some guns one bullet at a time takes a while, and enemies, especially bosses, can be relentless. I waffled between finding it cool and finding it frustrating. By the end, I’d decided I loved it.

The 2D characters and monsters are beautifully animated, and they look right at home in the town’s shadowy 3D streets and buildings. Every person and creature looks hand-drawn, with heavy inkwork reminiscent of Brian Michael Bendis’s early graphic novels like Torso. Light, flat colors against all that black give them the stark, high-contrast look of a bad photocopy. The 3D environments are fairly simple, but smart use of silhouettes, lighting, and painterly textures gives them depth and makes them feel foreboding.

Silver Pines is one of the best survival horror experiences I’ve had in a while. It’s one of my top Game of the Year contenders. The game’s vibes pushed just the right buttons, and I’ll be thinking about it for a long time.

Release date: October 8, 2026
Final Verdict:
Essential

Silver Pines

Silver Pines feels like a survival horror game tailor-made for me. One of the best games of the year.

Overall Score
10 /10
Played on SteamOS PC with review code provided by the publisher.
Previous
Previous

Kalanoro [Review]

Next
Next

Gently Packed Launches Into Steam Early Access Today, Bringing Some Much-Needed Calm to November 19 [Press Release]