Writer-director James Gray draws on his own family history for Paper Tiger, a crime drama about a Queens family under threat from the Russian mob.
Paper Tiger. Courtesy of NEON
Director James Gray’s latest, Paper Tiger, is a thrilling crime drama elevated by what might be career-best performances from Miles Teller, Scarlett Johansson, and Adam Driver. Like Gray’s previous film, Armageddon Time, this one draws directly from his family history. The collapse of the family he depicts echoes what his own family went through, from his mother’s illness and his father’s legal troubles to the moment Gray and his brother were threatened at knife point as teens. The result is as powerful a family melodrama as it is a crime thriller.
Miles Teller is Irwin Pearl, an engineer who is successful enough to get by in Queens with his wife Hester (Scarlett Johansson) and teenage sons Scott (Gavin Goudey) and Benjamin (Roman Engel). Irwin’s brother, former cop Gary (Adam Driver), approaches him with an irresistible opportunity. They’ll use Gary’s connections in the city and Irwin’s engineering smarts to advise businesses struggling to comply with environmental regulations. Their clients will be Russian immigrants who own businesses along the Gowanus Canal. Things quickly fall apart when Irwin takes his sons to visit one of the operations at night and witnesses men loading up barrels of oil for illegal dumping. It turns out the business owners are actually the Russian mob, and they threaten Irwin and his family.
Paper Tiger. Courtesy of NEON
Paper Tiger. Courtesy of NEON
In Armageddon Time, Jeremy Strong and Anne Hathaway played Irving and Esther, the fictional versions of Gray’s parents. Even the names here, Irwin and Hester, are close. Gray intended Strong and Hathaway to reprise their roles, but both had other commitments. That’s fine, because Teller and Johansson each turn in some of the strongest work of their careers. Johansson in particular is heartrending as Hester realizes that her husband put their children in danger, even as she’s quietly falling apart over a cancer diagnosis she’s keeping secret.
Adam Driver’s Gary Pearl, a composite of Gray’s uncle and other people in his father’s orbit, is my favorite part of the film. His bravado conceals his growing realization that he’s in over his head as he fails to protect his family. His thrilling yet understated gunfight near the end of the film is one of the most creative and well-staged shootouts I’ve seen on-screen in some time.
Cinematographer Joaquín Baca-Asay, a longtime collaborator of Gray’s, shot Paper Tiger on 35mm film. One of the things I love most about Paper Tiger is how it feels like it could have been made decades ago. It’s a movie about a family in 1986 that looks like it was shot in the mid-1970s, grittiness and all. Seeing it on the big screen was a joy.
Paper Tiger is a standout drama featuring some of the year’s strongest performances. While it’s disguised as a crime thriller, what stuck with me is the intensely personal portrait of a family in crisis.
Paper Tiger
Paper Tiger kept me on edge as an excellently realized crime thriller, but it’s the intensely personal melodrama about a family falling apart that makes it unforgettable.


Writer-director James Gray draws on his own family history for Paper Tiger, a crime drama about a Queens family under threat from the Russian mob.